Both sides of the concealed-weapons debate squared off last
week in anticipation of next month's showdown, when lawmakers
will decide whether to override Gov. Bob Holden's veto.
Gun-rights advocates, though concerned that they may not have
the votes to enact the law this year, argued that people should
not be precluded from defending themselves in an uncertain and
often dangerous world.
Bob Curtis, mental health director in Miami County, Kan., and
an instructor in defensive handgun techniques, said he had twice
scared off would-be attackers simply by having a gun in his
possession.
"Law-abiding citizens don't stop being law-abiding when
they carry weapons," Curtis said. "Criminals don't
stop being criminals. The (current) law just disarms people like
me."
Opponents argued that an armed society makes life more
dangerous, not less. Legalizing hidden guns, they said,
increases the chance of accidental shootings and undermines
broader efforts to reduce violence among young people.
Rep. Yvonne Wilson, a Kansas City Democrat, said guns were a
particular menace in her inner-city district. Their presence on
the street, she said, creates problems for children.
"I see more than needs to be seen with respect to gun
violence," Wilson said. "Concealed guns enhance the
opportunity for unnecessary violence and unnecessary loss of
life."
The forum, sponsored Thursday by the Kansas City Young
Republicans, came six weeks before the legislature is scheduled
to consider whether to override the governor's veto of a bill
legalizing concealed guns.
The crowd, which leaned heavily in favor of concealed
handguns, was told that concealed carry was unlikely to become
law this year.
Republican Reps. Shannon Cooper of Clinton and Bryan Pratt of
Blue Springs predicted that the House would vote to override the
governor's veto. But they said the Senate appeared to be at
least one vote short of the two-thirds necessary to override the
veto.
In his veto message, Holden, a Democrat, cited multiple
reasons for rejecting the legislation. He said it violated
federal law by allowing people convicted of domestic violence to
carry a concealed gun.
The bill, Holden wrote, would put the public at risk by
allowing concealed guns to be carried on to Little League
baseball fields and into restaurants, bars, child-care centers,
schools and churches if authorized by the owner or other
official.
The bill also flouts public opinion, Holden wrote, because it
is less restrictive and would require less training than the
concealed-weapons proposal that Missouri voters rejected in
1999. The governor also criticized the provision that makes
secret the identity of those with permits to carry concealed
guns.
At Thursday night's forum, Todd Elkins, an Independence
minister, joined in the criticism of the secrecy surrounding
those who want a permit to carry a concealed gun. Such a
provision would prevent the public from learning whether permit
holders committed crimes, he said.
Elkins, chairman of a coalition of faith-based groups called
Missouri Impact, called the concealed-carry bill anti-community
because it supersedes local control. He warned that the bill
would also allow people without concealed-gun permits or firearm
training to conceal a gun within their car.
Proponents of concealed carry noted that the 1999 ballot
proposal was favored by majorities in 104 of the state's 114
counties. Gary Davis, a former president of the Western Missouri
Shooters Alliance, said voters in Kansas City and St. Louis
should not be dictating public policy for the entire state.
Davis, who lives in the inner city, chided gun opponents for
claiming that guns would put children in danger.
"The children they are talking about are the ones doing
the killing," Davis said, citing a recent case in which
police accused a 15-year-old of a drive-by shooting.
He said he agreed with U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft,
who has said the problem is about culture, not about guns. Music
that encourages urban youths to be violent, deal drugs and treat
women disrespectfully leads to criminal behavior, Davis said. To
deal with criminals, law-abiding people need to be able to carry
guns to protect themselves, he said.
Kevin Jamison, a Gladstone lawyer who has worked to legalize
concealed weapons since 1991, promised that if the legislature
failed to override the governor's veto, gun-rights supporters
would be back with another bill next year.
"You have the right to defend yourself, but not the
right to the means of self-defense," Jamison said.
"You're left to duke it out with a guy who may have a
knife....It's not just. It's not fair. The legislature took our
right away from us in 1879, and we want it back."
Wilson, however, said such statements ignored the need for
people to work together to solve crime problems.
"What we're doing is raising the level of fear,"
Wilson said. "We've raised it so much that we're willing to
kill each other."
To reach Kit Wagar, Jefferson City
correspondent, call (816) 234-4440 or send e-mail to kwagar@kcstar.com.