With the stroke of a pen, Gov. Bob Holden on Thursday
blocked the latest attempt to legalize concealed weapons
in Missouri.
Holden vetoed the bill at a rally in St. Louis
County, where voters opposed legalizing concealed
weapons by more than 2-1 when the issue was put to a
statewide vote in 1999.
Holden called the bill "a misguided legislative
proposal that would overthrow the will of the people and
place the lives of countless Missourians in
jeopardy."
Gun-rights supporters were undeterred, saying they
are gearing up to try to override the veto when the
General Assembly meets again in September. With a
Republican majority in favor of concealed weapons and
many rural Democrats likely to defect from Holden's
side, the bill's supporters say they already might have
the votes.
Holden gave a litany of reasons for opposing the new
legislation: Required training is inadequate; guns would
be more available to children; permit holders from other
states with no training could carry guns in Missouri.
Holden also said people with a history of mental
illness and those convicted of domestic abuse could get
permits to carry guns. He said the legislation would
increase accidental shootings and would pose a risk to
police officers.
"We have already had this debate on concealed
weapons in Missouri and Missourians spoke loud and clear
with a resounding `No!' " Holden said.
Gun-rights advocates said they were not surprised by
the governor's action.
Kevin Jamison, president of the Western Missouri
Shooters Alliance, said Holden's veto meant that
Missouri residents continue to be denied a right
available to residents of nearly three dozen other
states. Kansas, however, does not allow concealed
weapons.
"This just shows he thinks Missourians are less
trustworthy, less reliable, less sane and more violent
than people in Arkansas," Jamison said. "Since
he doesn't trust us, we don't trust him to be governor.
And we'll vote accordingly."
Rep. Larry Crawford, the Centertown Republican who
sponsored the legislation, said Holden's reasons for
opposing the legislation were not borne out by the
experience of other states. Concealed carry laws have
not led to more accidental shootings, he said.
Experience shows that relatively few people who get
permits actually decide to carry weapons, Crawford said.
But criminals are less likely to attack because they
don't know who might be armed. People with guns can step
into emergency situations when police are not around, he
said.
"Maybe it means more law-abiding people with
guns are on the street," Crawford said. "But
that just helps reduce crime."
The Missouri bill, with its requirement for eight
hours of training and a live-fire test, has stiffer
training requirements than most other states, he said.
Crawford said the 1999 proposition to legalize
concealed guns -- which lost by 44,000 votes -- was not
an accurate expression of Missourians' attitudes because
turnout was only about 30 percent. The issue still
prevailed in 104 of the state's 114 counties.
Opponents of concealed carry scoffed at such
contentions. Todd Elkins, chairman of Missouri Impact,
an inter-faith group of congregations, said Holden
should be commended for standing up to the gun lobby.
The 10 counties -- including Jackson -- and the city
of St. Louis that defeated the proposition are the large
jurisdictions that provide most of the taxes and the
jobs that power the state's economy, Elkins said. By
trying to overturn a statewide vote, the legislature
undermines confidence in government, he said.
Republicans have been pushing gun rights as an
emotional issue to use against Democratic candidates.
But concealed guns are bad public policy, Elkins said.
They degrade the quality of public life by making it
less safe.
"They are all about an individual saying his
rights are elevated above the common good," Elkins
said. "It says, `We don't trust the police. We
don't trust government. The only person I can trust is
me.' "
Elkins pointed to the shooting at a factory Tuesday
night in Jefferson City. A worker concealed a handgun to
get it into a factory and then opened fire, killing
three people and wounding five others.
The man had no criminal record. He obtained the gun
legally. And the police followed procedures in approving
his purchase of the gun.
"Everything was done correctly, yet an obviously
disturbed person got a high-quality gun and killed
people," Elkins said.
But Crawford and Jamison said the Jefferson City
shooting showed the need for a concealed carry law.
Police can't respond fast enough in such a situation,
but other workers could have stopped him if they had
been armed, Crawford said.
Jamison noted that the man was stopped after
exchanging gunfire with police officers.
"The first person with a gun who ran into him,
stopped him," Jamison said. "If a civilian had
had a gun, he would have been stopped earlier."
Holden rejected that argument. He noted the adage
"a little knowledge is a dangerous thing."
Police officers undergo hundreds of hours of training
and still have difficulty hitting their target while
under extreme stress.
"What we need to do is invest in law enforcement
and community policing," Holden said. "Most
people won't have the training to defend themselves... I
have two boys that I take to Little League and soccer
games. Do you want fans carrying guns to these games?
That's not the direction our state ought to be
moving."
The concealed guns bill is HB349.