![]() http://newstribune.com/stories/100403/sta_1004030029.asp |
| Saturday,
October 4, 2003 Trend in concealed gun laws: Conceal who has permits By SCOTT CHARTON Missouri's new law, enacted when the Legislature overrode Gov. Bob
Holden's veto last month, bars identification of concealed weapons
permit holders -- even though separate applications to sheriffs to
purchase guns have been open records for years, and remain so.
The new law makes it a misdemeanor for law enforcement to disclose
names of holders of concealed gun permits issued by Missouri sheriffs
starting Oct. 11.
An Associated Press review of the four concealed gun laws enacted
this year -- in Colorado, Minnesota, Missouri and New Mexico -- showed
that each bars public identification by name of permit holders.
Legislation was filed but not approved this year in at least two
other states, Tennessee and Texas, to close currently accessible
listings by name of concealed gun permit holders.
Gun control advocates accuse concealed guns boosters and the National
Rifle Association of pressing a national strategy to keep the public
from scrutinizing who is licensed to carry concealed guns.
"It's simple: the proponents of concealed carry do not want to
have news stories that a permit holder pulled a gun and shot someone.
The improper use of concealed weapons is the strongest argument we have
against these laws," said Luis Tolley, spokesman for the Brady
Campaign, a leading gun control group.
But the NRA strongly defends barring public scrutiny of who is
licensed to carry a concealed gun, and would like to see lists closed in
every state, a spokeswoman said.
"There is no need for the public to know who has a permit,"
said NRA spokeswoman Kelly Hobbs. "Research has shown that the
principal reason right-to-carry laws deter crime is that criminals do
not know who is armed."
She added that secrecy of the names of permit holders "is
something we support and we want to see included in all right-to-carry
laws."
In Missouri, the state open records law assumes as basic policy that
government paperwork is public unless specifically exempted.
State Rep. Larry Crawford, R-Centertown, said the records closure was
put into the concealed gun law because of "concerns that
publicizing who has a license could lead to those people being targeted
for theft of their guns."
Charles Davis, executive director of the Freedom of Information
Center at the University of Missouri-Columbia, called the reasons for
closing the concealed gun permit lists "ludicrous."
For example, Davis said, a parent wouldn't be able to find out
independently whether a babysitter carried a concealed gun, or a
homeowner couldn't discover whether a bothersome neighbor had a permit.
He said news organizations couldn't serve the public because they
wouldn't be able to report on criminal actions by hidden handgun
licensees.
"This is bad public policy on so many levels that it boggles the
mind. What the legislators have essentially done is allow government
only to have that data, so therefore the public has no way to answer any
questions about the holders of these permits," Davis said.
"This essentially says there is no public interest in knowing who
has concealed weapons permits, and I would disagree fundamentally with
that."
The Missouri Press Association, which represents the state's daily
and weekly newspapers, objects to the closed records and will seek to
get the records opened next year, said executive director Doug Crews.
Crawford said he would be willing to discuss "technical
changes," perhaps including the records closure.
"But I'd rather let the law work for a couple of years,"
the lawmaker said.
Missouri became the 45th state to authorize concealed guns in some
fashion, with the override of Holden's veto. Advocates say the laws have
contributed to drops in violent crime by deterring criminals unsure
whether a potential victim might be armed. Holden and other critics say
more guns in circulation will lead to more gun violence.
On the Net:
Missouri concealed guns law: www.house.state.mo.us/bills03/biltxt/truly/HB0349T.HTM
National Rifle Association: www.nra.org
Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence www.bradycampaign.com [Ed. Why ignore the MOCCW site, the WMSA site, the GCLA site?] |